Many customers ask about the differences between iron filter media. With so many options—tanks, valves, and media types—it’s easy to feel overwhelmed.

Here’s a breakdown of the most popular types: Pro-OX, Filox, MangOX, and Pyrolox are all brand names for solid manganese dioxide media. We recommend Pro-OX, a high-quality option that’s over 80% pure manganese ore and NSF-certified for drinking water.

In contrast, some countries sell lower-purity manganese media (often under 50%). Pro-OX stands out for its superior oxidation and porosity, making it our top choice.

Coated manganese media, like Greensand or Birm, are also used in iron filters. These have a thin manganese oxide layer over silica. While effective, they don’t last as long as solid media—Greensand typically needs replacement every 5 years. Solid media can last decades.

One downside is weight: solid media weighs 120–140 lbs/ft³ vs. Greensand’s 80 lbs/ft³. Heavier media needs a higher backwash flow rate, so if your well pump has low flow, Greensand may be a better option.

Overall, solid manganese media like Pro-OX offer stronger performance, longer lifespan, and higher service flow rates, allowing for smaller tanks that use less space and water.

If iron bacteria are present, we recommend installing a chlorine feeder before the filter to oxidize iron and kill bacteria.

Introduction

Iron filter media is crucial in removing iron and manganese from water. Various options are available, and it’s essential to understand the differences between them to make an informed decision. Iron filters are a crucial component in water treatment systems, addressing the different forms of iron present in water, such as clear water iron, red water iron, ferrous iron, and organic iron, each presenting unique challenges for filtration. This article will explore the different types of iron filter media and their characteristics, effectiveness, and maintenance requirements.

Iron filters can enhance water quality by removing iron and other contaminants. Additionally, combining iron filters with a water softener can ensure the complete removal of both ferric and ferrous iron, significantly improving water quality and preventing issues such as scale buildup.

Introduction to Iron Filters

Iron filters are a crucial component in water treatment systems, designed to remove dissolved iron, manganese, and hydrogen sulfide from water. These filters are essential for maintaining water quality in homes with well water, as iron can cause staining, unpleasant tastes and odors, and support the growth of iron bacteria.

The best iron filter for well water is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and key factors to consider when choosing an iron filter include longevity, efficiency, and cost. Iron filters can enhance water quality by removing iron and other contaminants, and the right iron filter can be tailored to a home’s specific needs and budget.

Iron Filter Media Options

There are several types of iron filter media available, including:

• Solid manganese dioxide filter media (e.g., Pro-OX, Filox, MangOX)
• Coated manganese media (e.g., Greensand)
• Birm
• Pyrolox

Each type of media has its unique characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages. The filtration process converts dissolved iron into solid particles that can be filtered out, utilizing various filter media to achieve this.

For example, solid manganese dioxide filter media is considered the gold standard in iron filter media due to its high purity and effectiveness. Filter sand plays a crucial role in the filtration process by forming a layer of manganese dioxide over time, which enhances its catalytic properties and effectiveness in removing impurities.

Iron Removal Processes

Iron removal processes involve the use of filter media, such as manganese dioxide, to oxidize soluble ferrous iron into insoluble ferric iron, which can then be removed from the water. The oxidation process can be enhanced by the use of dissolved oxygen, potassium permanganate, or other oxidizing agents.

Iron filters can also remove other contaminants, such as manganese and hydrogen sulfide, and are often used in conjunction with water softeners to provide a comprehensive solution for iron removal. The type of iron filter media used can affect the efficiency of the iron removal process, with some media types, such as manganese greensand, being more effective than others.

Characteristics and Effectiveness

The effectiveness of iron filter media depends on several factors, including its purity, density, and surface area. Solid manganese dioxide filter media, for instance, has a higher purity (>80%) and density (120-140 lbs per cubic foot) compared to coated manganese media (e.g., Greensand). This results in a stronger oxidizing ability and higher service flow rate.

Coated manganese media, on the other hand, uses a light coating of manganese oxide over silica or other granular minerals. While it’s less expensive than solid manganese dioxide filter media, it’s generally less effective and has a shorter lifespan.

Factors Affecting Iron Filter Performance

Several factors can affect the performance of iron filters, including the type of filter media used, the flow rate of the water, and the pH level of the water. Iron filters require regular maintenance, including periodic backwashing, to remove accumulated iron and other contaminants. The service flow rate of the filter can also impact its performance, with higher flow rates requiring more frequent backwashing.

Additionally, the presence of other contaminants, such as manganese and hydrogen sulfide, can affect the performance of the iron filter. Regular testing and maintenance can help ensure optimal performance of the iron filter and prevent issues such as clogging and reduced water pressure.

Choosing the Right Filter Media for Your Iron Filter

When selecting the right filter media for your iron filter, consider the following factors:

• Iron and manganese levels in your water
• Flow rate requirements
• Space constraints
• Maintenance preferences
• Budget

When selecting the right filter media for your iron filter, it is crucial to understand that water flows significantly impact the effectiveness of iron and manganese filters.

Solid manganese dioxide filter media is generally preferred due to its longer lifespan and higher service flow rate. However, coated manganese media may be a better option for users with insufficient well pump flow rates or those who prioritize affordability. The use of other media in conjunction with your primary filter media can enhance the overall performance of iron removal systems.

The design of the filtration system can also impact the performance. Ensuring optimal system performance involves choosing the right filter media, maintaining proper water chemistry, adjusting flow rates, and conducting regular maintenance.

Filtration System Design

The design of the filtration system can also impact the performance of the iron filter. A good filtration system needs a media bed deep enough to remove iron and other contaminants, plus a backwash system to clear out buildup. The media type affects system design—materials like crushed anthracite coal may need a deeper bed. Water pH also matters; acidic water may require different media than neutral water.

Maintenance and Cost Considerations

Regular maintenance is crucial to ensure the effectiveness and longevity of your iron filter media. This includes:

• Backwashing: Regular backwashing is necessary to remove accumulated iron and manganese from the media.
• Replacing the media: Depending on the type of media, replacement may be necessary every 5-20 years.
• Chlorine injection: Chlorine injection may be required to enhance the media’s performance and lifespan.

The cost of iron filter media varies depending on the type and quality. Solid manganese dioxide filter media is generally more expensive than coated manganese media. However, its longer lifespan and higher effectiveness may justify the additional cost.

Like, Share, and Join Our Community

Share